Oracle SQL

    Tag Archives: distributed transactions

    Deceptive commit after select from dblink.

    Posted on October 13, 2012 by Sayan Malakshinov Posted in commit, documentation, oracle, remote statements, trace, transactions Leave a comment

    Recently on our russian forum we discussed about distributed transaction: is “insert /*+ append */ into x select * from t@dblink” a distributed transaction or not?
    According to the documentation – no:

    A distributed transaction includes one or more statements that, individually or as a group, update data on two or more distinct nodes of a distributed database

    And Tom Kyte said the same:

    In the following, we do not have a distributed transaction when we just insert /*+ append */ into local_table select * from remote@table; – we just have a single site transaction.

    But v$global_transaction(but v$transaction), another part of documentation and v$lock(type=’DX’) assure that it is.

    Distributed statement: A statement that accesses data on two or more distinct nodes/instances of a distributed database.
    A remote statement accesses data on one remote node of a distributed database.

    Who is right?

    But it not so interesting as my another finding: commit after simple “select * from dblink” would be “read-only” commit on local db, but on remote it became “read-only” rollback! Except cases when there was any dml in that transaction(with no difference local or not). But how Oracle determining: read-only or not, execute commit or rollback?

    Yet another interesting thing: If we do a few times “commit” after “select from dblink”, then, as expected, rollback will be executed only once on remote. But when we closing our session, there is another commit on remote(real read-only commit).

    Tests below: Continue reading→

    commit distributed transactions remote statements rollback

    Simple Android Oracle client

    Get it on Google Play

    About us

    photo Sayan Malakshinov

    Oracle ACE Associate Oracle ACE Associate
    Oracle performance tuning expert
    Russia / Moscow / Transmedia Dynamics
    photo Bair Malakshinov

    Ph.d candidate
    Senior Oracle Developer
    Poland / Cracow / Luxoft

    Popular Posts

    • Differences between integer(int) in SQL and PL/SQL 0 comments
    • Deterministic function vs scalar subquery caching. Part 1 8 comments
    • Amazing optimization of getting distinct values from the index, and TopN for each of them 4 comments
    • SQL*Plus tips #6: Colorizing output 4 comments
    • SQL*Plus tips #5: sql_text/sql_fulltext formatting(sql beatifier) 13 comments
    • SQL*Plus tips. #1 5 comments
    • A couple of well-known but often forgotten things for PL/SQL developers 2 comments
    • SYS_OP_MAP_NONNULL is in the documentation now 0 comments
    • SQL*Plus tips #4: Branching execution 0 comments
    • Oracle 12c: Lateral, row_limiting_clause 3 comments

    Recent Posts

    • Top-N again: fetch first N rows only vs rownum
    • Docker with Oracle database: install patches automatically
    • Top N biggest tables (with lobs, indexes and nested table)
    • “Collection iterator pickler fetch”: pipelined vs simple table functions
    • SQL*Plus tips #8: How to read the output of dbms_output without “serveroutput on”

    Email Subscription

    Recent Comments

    • SQL*Plus 256 Colours in terminal | EDUARDO CLARO on SQL*Plus tips #6: Colorizing output
    • A simple SQL*Plus parameter parser | EDUARDO CLARO on SQL*Plus tips. #1
    • Sayan Malakshinov on “Collection iterator pickler fetch”: pipelined vs simple table functions
    • Frits on “Collection iterator pickler fetch”: pipelined vs simple table functions
    • SQL*Plus tips #8: How to read the output of dbms_output without 'serveroutput on' - SSWUG.ORG on SQL*Plus tips #8: How to read the output of dbms_output without “serveroutput on”
    • Adaptive serial direct path read decision ignores object statistics since 12.1 - SSWUG.ORG on Adaptive serial direct path read decision ignores object statistics since 12.1
    • Oracle issues after upgrade to 12.2 - SSWUG.ORG on Oracle issues after upgrade to 12.2
    • Ampersand instead of colon for bind variables - SSWUG.ORG on Ampersand instead of colon for bind variables
    • Евгений Бабин on Oracle issues after upgrade to 12.2
    • Oracle SQL | How even empty trigger increases redo generation on Triggers and Redo: changes on 12.2

    Blogroll

    • Alex Fatkulin
    • Alexander Anokhin
    • Andrey Nikolaev
    • Charles Hooper
    • Christian Antognini
    • Coskan Gundogar
    • David Fitzjarrell
    • Igor Usoltsev
    • Jonathan Lewis
    • Karl Arao
    • Mark Bobak
    • Martin Bach
    • Martin Berger
    • Neil Chandler
    • Randolf Geist
    • Richard Foote
    • Riyaj Shamsudeen
    • Tanel Poder
    • Timur Akhmadeev
    • Valentin Nikotin

    Categories

    Aggregated by OraNA Aggregated by OraFAQ

    Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org
    ©Sayan Malakshinov. Oracle SQL